RocketOS v6.0.0

Rocket Comics flight systems initializing.

Rocket Comics

Welcome to Rocket Comics

Your Hero Lives at Rocket Comics!

All reviews

Batman: Gotham by Gaslight


Batman: Gotham by Gaslight cover

Batman: Gotham by Gaslight takes one of comics’ most obvious great ideas — Batman hunting Jack the Ripper — and somehow manages to execute the idea even better than it sounds.

Writer Brian Augustyn relocates Bruce Wayne to the late 19th century, stripping away the Batmobile, computers, satellites, and most of the technological advantages we associate with Batman. What’s left is the part of the character that matters most: the detective.

Batman (err, sorry...The Batman) fits the Victorian setting naturally so the story never feels gimmicky.

Bruce returns to Gotham after years of training just as Jack the Ripper begins murdering women in the city, and he soon becomes personally entangled in the investigation. The story moves quickly, but still feels appropriately foggy, gothic, and grim. Gotham has always looked like it belongs somewhere between a cathedral and a nightmare, so gas lamps and horse-drawn carriages suit it remarkably well.

The mystery itself isn’t much of a baffler. The identity of Jack the Ripper is telegraphed fairly early, but solving the crime isn’t really the point. The mystery is the vehicle that carries us toward the inevitable confrontation between Batman and Jack.

That isn’t a criticism of Augustyn’s writing. Quite the opposite. He does an impressive job of building an entire Victorian Gotham in only 48 pages.

Then there’s Mike Mignola’s artwork, inked by P. Craig Russell.

This was years before Hellboy, but the DNA is already there: heavy shadows, looming architecture, figures emerging from darkness, and the sense that something unpleasant is always waiting just beyond the edge of the panel. His Batman looks less like a superhero than something Victorian criminals might genuinely believe crawled out of Hell.

You can see Mignola developing the visual language that would later reach full maturity in Hellboy and the wider B.P.R.D. universe. It’s a shame he never returned to wander Gotham’s shadowy back alleys.

Gotham by Gaslight would later become the template for DC’s Elseworlds concept, and it’s easy to understand why. Even though the story might have benefited from a little more room to breathe, it remains a remarkably effective combination of mystery, horror, superhero adventure, and atmosphere.

This Batman returned in the Jules Verne-flavored Master of the Future, later appeared in Countdown Presents: The Search for Ray Palmer, and eventually saw his world expanded again in Batman: Gotham by Gaslight – The Kryptonian Age. Those stories range from interesting to very good, but none quite recapture the strange magic of the original.

I’d love to see another creator revisit this version of Batman with a proper Victorian mystery. Put him against H. H. Holmes in the Murder Castle. Pair him with Sherlock Holmes against Professor Moriarty. The gaslit streets are simply too good a setting to leave behind.

Until then, when the weather turns brisk and the shadows grow longer, return to Victorian Gotham and follow the Batman as he hunts a killer who, in another telling, would boast that he "gave birth to the 20th century.”

Rex Stratos, Rocket Corpsman

Heads up, Rocket Readers!

Rockets are the key to understanding a Rocket Review. More rockets mean a better read — from one (“Red Alert”) to five (“Blast Off!”). Red and yellow signal caution, cyan means standby, and green means GO! (Seriously! Go buy this comic now! That's an order!) Beware! Most reviews contain, at least, light spoilers.

  • Red Alert

  • Yellow Alert

  • Standby

  • All Systems Go!

  • Blast Off!